The crew of Britain’s most advanced man o’war have celebrated the birthday of their Service’s oldest and proudest division.
The Jolly Roger – unofficial battle ensign of Royal Navy’s submarine flotilla – was ‘raised’ aboard hunter-killer HMS Astute on her maiden patrol.

IN THE cramped confines of Britain’s newest and most hi-tech underwater warrior, today’s submariners celebrate the Silent Service’s proudest tradition – 100 years to the day it was born.
The Jolly Roger – unofficial battle ensign of the Royal Navy’s submarine force – ‘flies’ in the mess of hunter-killer HMS Astute on her maiden patrol.
A century ago – and at the cutting edge of the naval technology of the day – HMS E9 claimed the first kill by a British submarine, German cruiser SMS Hela.

A contemporary newspaper sketch of E9’s return, flying the Jolly Roger, in 1914. Courtesy of George Malcolmson
On her return to port, the boat’s crew raised the Jolly Roger – a slap in the face for the fuddy-duddies in the Admiralty who thought submariners little better than pirates.
Since then the banner has been flown frequently by successful British submarines returning from patrols – by VC winners such as Cdr David Wanklyn and his record-breaking HMS Upholder in World War 2, to HMS Triumph which launched Tomahawk missiles at Col Gaddafi’s military machine in Libya in 2011.
There’s been no such action for Astute, on her first operational patrol since February, but her 98 crew time were determine to mark the 100th birthday of the flag, not just making one in cloth, but baking one as well (and a White Ensign just for good measure).

The flag flies after HMS Triumph hammered Col Gaddafi’s military machine in 2011 with her Tomahawk missiles
“The Jolly Roger sets the Submarine Service apart from our surface brethren. It is a symbol of the camaraderie and fighting spirit that characterise us. Though we have made huge technological advances in the Service, embodied by Astute herself, we will never forget the history of the submarines that have served before us,” said Cdr Gareth Jenkins, CO of the Faslane-based boat.
AB Ben Coy said he and his shipmates took great pride in making Astute’s flag. “The Jolly Roger is created onboard and it is unique to every submarine,” he said. “Our Jolly Roger was the result of a lot of hard work from all of the crew with every member of the ship’s company putting a stitch into the flag. It is great that the traditions of the Submarine Service are kept alive.”
Astute’s coxswain – the most senior rating aboard – Alan Wakefield added: “The Service is necessarily covert and by its nature not a lot is known about what submarines do during their operational periods.
“The Jolly Roger has been a way of showing the public what our submarines have done for 100 years – the Jolly Rogers hung in the Royal Navy Submarine Museum in Gosport and around the United Kingdom are pockets of history that document parts of what the Service has achieved.”

HMS E9, courtesy of George Malcolmson
A legend is born
His Majesty’s Submarine E9 surfaced off the German fortress island of Heligoland and saw the cruiser Hela emerging from the morning mist and drizzle.
Her captain Lieutenant Max Horton fired two torpedoes at a range of just 600 yards.
The attack lasted no more than 15 minutes, but E9 was forced to dive almost immediately as the Germans tried to hunt her down.

Some of the elaborate additions to Jolly Rogers made by submariners
She spent the next hour hiding before Horton dared to raise his periscope. When he did, the German warship was gone.
Only two crew of the obsolete cruiser were lost when she went down, but the loss of the Hela marked the first German ship lost to a submarine and the first success of Silent Service – just 13 years old at the outbreak of the Great War.
The sinking of the Hela – eight days after HMS Pathfinder had the unfortunate ‘honour’ of being the first Royal Navy warship sunk by U-boat – confirmed the potency of the submarine.
Some of the old guard in the Admiralty had dismissed the new weapon as “underhand, unfair and damned un-English” in the run up to war and branded their crews pirates who deserved hanging.
Horton seized the ‘pirate’ tag and turned it on its head, getting his signaller to produce a Jolly Roger which was flown from the periscope as the boat returned to base in Harwich – giving birth to a Silent Service tradition, although not instantaneously.
“The skull and crossbones in the modern era are not exclusive to submarines – and they were not universally accepted within the Submarine Service,” says George Malcolmson, archivist at the RN Submarine Museum in Gosport.
“The Admiralty certainly took a disliking to the flag – at the time it was keen to distance our ‘good’ submarines with German submarines which were ‘bad’.”

HMS Turbulent flies the pirate flag after cruise missile launches in the Gulf
As a result Horton’s actions when E9 returned from her historic patrol were not widely repeated during the Great War (in fact, the Admiralty claimed his flag flying was a one-off, but other successful boats did copy Horton’s lead).
A generation later, British submariners resurrected the Jolly Roger with gusto – providing they had achieved a success on their patrol.
Initially, crews simply ‘chalked up’ the number of ships sunk, but in time they would add numerous embellishments: aircraft (for downed planes); daggers (for ‘cloak and dagger’ operations); a sheep’s head (for ramming an enemy vessel); lifebelts (for seamen plucked from the ocean).
Whatever the tally of a patrol, the Admiralty only permitted the flag hoisted when it reached the boom at the edge of a naval base – and flown only until sunset.
The tradition is maintained to this day – HMS Conqueror is the last submarine to raise the standard after sinking a ship (the Belgrano in the Falklands), while HMS Turbulent and Triumph hoisted the Jolly Roger following operations against Saddam Hussein and Colonel Gaddafi respectively to mark not torpedoings but successful Tomahawk missile strikes against targets hundreds of miles away.